How Much Heat a Radiant Floor Can Put Out per Sq Ft
Calculations follow ACCA Manual J/S/D procedures and ASHRAE standards.
On this page
A heated floor puts out about 2 BTU/h per square foot for every degree its surface runs above the room air. At the 85°F surface that John Siegenthaler gives as the recommended maximum where feet rest on the floor, that's about 30 BTU/h per sq ft in a 70°F room, and the 80°F wood floor limit in NWFA's 2019 guidelines, as Hardwood Floors magazine reports it, cuts it to about 20.
Water temperature decides whether the floor reaches that ceiling, and the water a floor needs depends on what sits between the tube and your feet. So the check runs in two steps: the heating load per square foot of floor that has tubing in it, then the water temperature your floor construction needs to deliver it. Our free BTU per square foot calculator gives the whole-house heating load, and you divide it by the floor area you'll tube to get the first number.
How many BTU per square foot can a radiant floor put out?
Upward output is about 2.0 BTU/h per sq ft for each °F of floor surface above room air, the coefficient Siegenthaler calls commonly accepted for heated floors. In a 70°F room that's 20 BTU/h per sq ft at an 80°F surface, 30 at 85°F and 40 at 90°F. The surface limit sets the ceiling.
| Average floor surface, 70°F room | Upward output, BTU/h per sq ft | Where that surface limit comes from |
|---|---|---|
| 80°F | 20 | NWFA 2019 guidelines for installed wood floors, as reported by Hardwood Floors magazine |
| 85°F | 30 | Siegenthaler's recommended maximum where there's prolonged foot contact |
| 90°F | 40 | Bathing areas, locker rooms and pool surrounds, per the same Hardwood Floors article |
Plumbing & Mechanical § Heating a thermos bottle house"The commonly accepted upward heat flow coefficient for heated floors is 2.0 Btu/hr./ft.2 per degree F difference between the floor surface and room air temperatures." - John Siegenthaler, pmmag.com
The numbers are averages across the whole floor. A floor over the tubes runs warmer than the floor between them, and Mark Eatherton calls the 30 figure a limit of human physiology, set by skin in contact with the floor. Not every wood floor maker holds to 80°F either, so the flooring maker's own limit is the one to design to.
What floor temperature does your heating load need?
Divide the room's design heating load by the floor area that has tubing, then add half that number to the room temperature. In our calculator's table, a tight 2015 two-story house of 2,000 sq ft needs 12.4 BTU/h per sq ft in zone 3A (Atlanta) and 20.1 in zone 7 (Duluth) at zone-level design temperatures, a 76.2°F and an 80.1°F floor if all of it is heated.
That rule is Siegenthaler's 2.0 coefficient turned around. The loads below are the 2015 column of the table on our BTU per square foot calculator, which runs a simplified ACCA Manual J 8th Edition whole-house load. The table's house is a 2,000 sq ft two-story house with a tight envelope and ducts inside conditioned space, and each row uses an approximate design temperature for its climate zone, which can differ from the city's own. In the last two columns we assumed tubing under 1,700 of the 2,000 sq ft, leaving the floor under cabinets, tubs and closets bare. That share is our assumption, so use your own layout.
| IECC climate zone in our table | Heating load, BTU/h per sq ft | Floor surface, all 2,000 sq ft heated | Load per tubed sq ft at 1,700 sq ft | Floor surface at 1,700 sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4C Seattle | 10.4 | 75.2°F | 12.2 | 76.1°F |
| 3A Atlanta | 12.4 | 76.2°F | 14.6 | 77.3°F |
| 5B Denver | 14.9 | 77.5°F | 17.5 | 78.8°F |
| 5A Chicago | 16.9 | 78.5°F | 19.9 | 79.9°F |
| 6A Minneapolis | 18.2 | 79.1°F | 21.4 | 80.7°F |
| 7 Duluth | 20.1 | 80.1°F | 23.6 | 81.8°F |
The floor surfaces are our arithmetic on the page's loads. Every row stays under 85°F. Against the NWFA 80°F limit for wood, the zone 7 house sits right at the line with every square foot heated, and the zone 6A house goes over at 80.7°F once 300 sq ft go without tubing. The 1985 houses in the same table need 28.1 to 31.9 BTU/h per sq ft in the Chicago, Minneapolis and Duluth zones. Those 1985 numbers include attic duct losses that a radiant house doesn't have, so run your own house in the calculator with the attic duct box unchecked.
To get your number, enter the house in the calculator, uncheck "Ducts run through an unconditioned attic" for a radiant-only house, and divide the heating load by the square feet you'll actually tube. That's a whole-house load. A sunroom or a room with a wall of glass can sit well above the house average, and room-by-room loads are part of the Pro plan. It's a preliminary estimate for a quote. When the AHJ wants a load calculation with the permit, run it in ACCA-approved Manual J software.
What water temperature does each floor type need?
It depends on the layers above the tube. In Caleffi's idronics 12, 20 BTU/h per sq ft from a bare 4-inch slab with 6-inch tube spacing takes about 87.5°F average water. The same output through a covering of R-1.0 at 12-inch spacing takes 112.5°F. For idronics 25's plate floor, with R-1.0 for the 3/4-inch subfloor and covering together, our arithmetic on Caleffi's formula gives about 126°F. A finish floor with more R-value needs hotter water.
| Floor construction (Caleffi) | Average water for 20 BTU/h per sq ft, 70°F room | Supply water |
|---|---|---|
| 4-inch slab, no covering, 6-inch tube spacing | 87.5°F | 95°F to 98°F, Caleffi's estimate |
| 4-inch slab, R-1.0 covering, 12-inch tube spacing | 112.5°F | 120°F to 123°F, Caleffi's estimate |
| Plates under a 3/4-inch wood subfloor, 1/2-inch tube at 8 inches, R-1.0 subfloor plus covering | 125.6°F, our arithmetic from q = 0.36 x (water - room) | Depends on the loop's temperature drop |
The slab rows come straight from idronics 12, for a slab with the tubing at about mid-depth and at least R-10 under and at the edges. The plate row comes from figure 3-20 of idronics 25, where Caleffi's chart for that floor stops at 120°F average water and 18 BTU/h per sq ft. Our 125.6°F takes Caleffi's formula a little past the end of the chart, and the issue says its formulas can estimate output at other water and room temperatures.
Caleffi also gives typical ranges in idronics 12: average water of 120°F to 140°F for plates above the subfloor under design load, and 130°F to 150°F for plates below the subfloor, depending on the output needed and the finish flooring's R-value. Push the plate formula to 30 BTU/h per sq ft and that R-1.0 floor asks for about 153°F average water, our arithmetic again. Under a wood floor you'd also be past the 80°F surface limit by then.
Why does staple-up without plates come up short?
Tubing stapled to the subfloor with no plates touches the wood over a tiny share of its surface, and Siegenthaler describes the rest of its heat moving by convection and radiation, with poor geometry for either. His opinion is that plateless staple-up is a possibility only where the floor has to deliver less than 15 BTU/h per sq ft.
In a 2002 column Siegenthaler described three plateless jobs he'd been called about in one week. In the carpeted bedrooms of one, the floor water reached 148°F at -10°F outdoor design and the rooms were still short of heat. He also listed finish floor damage on plateless systems: cracked tile, striped vinyl and carpet, and warped hardwood.
Conduction needs contact area. Plates spread that heat across the floor, and that's why idronics 25's floor panel uses 6-inch aluminum plates on 8-inch tube spacing. Insulation under the tube matters too. For plates laid on top of the subfloor, idronics 12 calls for at least R-19 under the floor over heated or semi-heated space and R-30 over unheated space. The issue gives no figure for plates under the subfloor.
What supply temperature does the 1,600 sq ft staple-up house need?
By our estimate, about 130°F to hold 70°F at 0°F outdoors, 127°F to 132°F depending on our assumptions. That's from two points the owner gave: a supply set around 114°F held 70°F at 20°F outdoors, and 120°F in, 109°F back left the house at 63°F to 64°F at 0°F. That makes 0.7°F to 0.9°F more supply per degree colder outside, the slope of an outdoor reset curve.
This question comes from an r/hvacadvice thread. The house is about 1,600 sq ft on a crawlspace with foam board under the floor, wood floors, a Navien combi the owner lists as 199,000 BTU, one thermostat and no outdoor sensor. The owner thinks the tubing is stapled up without plates. At 0°F outside, with the supply set at 122°F, the readings were 120°F supply and 109°F return and the house sat at 63°F to 64°F. The owner didn't say whether those were taken on the boiler side or at the floor loops.
Here's the estimate, ours, assuming the floor's output follows the water-to-room temperature difference like Caleffi's formulas:
- At 20°F outdoors the supply was set around 114°F and the house held 70°F. The owner didn't give a return reading, so we assumed the same 11°F drop, for an average of 108.5°F, 38.5°F above the room.
- At 0°F outdoors the average water was 114.5°F, about 51°F above a 63.5°F room. That's 1.32 times the first temperature difference. The indoor to outdoor difference was 63.5°F, against 50°F at 20°F outdoors, which is 1.27 times the first heat loss. The two ratios are close, so the floor behaves about as the formula says.
- Holding 70°F at 0°F means 1.4 times the heat loss at 20°F. That takes about 54°F between the water and the room, an average near 124°F and a supply near 130°F, assuming the same flow, since the drop grows with output. If the drop at 20°F was smaller than 11°F, or the actual supply ran 2°F under the 114°F setting as it did at 0°F, the answer moves to between 127°F and 132°F.
The owner later turned the supply up to 130°F and reported 70°F, then backed it down to 126°F and held 68°F to 70°F with single digits outside. For comparison, idronics 25's plate floor, where the 3/4-inch subfloor and covering together come to R-1.0, would give about 19.4 BTU/h per sq ft at that 124°F average by Caleffi's formula. A solid wood floor on top of the subfloor adds R-value, so a plated panel under this house's floor would give less than that at the same water temperature.
What if the floor can't carry the room?
Add a second heat emitter for the load the floor can't carry within its limit. Caleffi's idronics 25 sizes it to run on the same water as the floor. Hardwood Floors' article on the NWFA guidelines says the designer must add other heat when a wood floor would need more than 20 BTU/h per sq ft. In idronics 25, plated drywall walls give 0.8 BTU/h per sq ft per °F of water over room air.
At 120°F average water in a 70°F room, idronics 25's formulas give 40 BTU/h per sq ft for a plated drywall wall and 35.5 for a plated drywall ceiling, against 18 for its R-1.0 plated floor. Panel radiators and fan coils are the other options it works through.
Here's the order we'd follow on a floor that's short:
- Run the whole-house heating load in the BTU per square foot calculator and divide it by the square feet that have tubing.
- Add half that number to the room temperature to get the floor surface. Compare it with 85°F, or with 80°F or the flooring maker's own limit for wood.
- Read the average water temperature your construction needs from the table above, and set your outdoor reset so the supply gets there on the design day.
- If the surface or the water comes out too high, plan plates, a wall or ceiling panel, a panel radiator or a fan coil for the rest of the load.
Start with the load. Enter the house in the BTU per square foot calculator for your ZIP, then divide the heating load by the square feet you'll tube.
Sources
- John Siegenthaler, "Heating a Thermos Bottle House," Plumbing & Mechanical, October 1, 2006, pmmag.com
- John Siegenthaler, "Cool to the touch," Plumbing & Mechanical, October 22, 2018, pmmag.com
- John Siegenthaler, "Plateless in Radiantville," Plumbing & Mechanical, July 3, 2002, pmmag.com
- Mark Eatherton, "So you think you know radiant," Plumbing & Mechanical, September 28, 2016, pmmag.com
- "Designing and Installing Radiant Floors with the 2019 NWFA Guidelines," Hardwood Floors, January 31, 2020, hardwoodfloorsmag.com
- Caleffi, idronics 12, Hydronic Fundamentals, caleffi.com
- Caleffi, idronics 25, Lowering Water Temperature in Existing Hydronic Heating Systems, July 2019, caleffi.com
- r/hvacadvice thread with the question, "Cannot keep house warm with radiant under floor," reddit.com
Related guides
How Much Hydronic Baseboard a Room Needs at 180°F or 140°F
· 10 min read
Window AC on a 15 or 20 Amp Circuit and When It Needs Its Own
· 11 min read
Zone Valves vs Zone Circulators for Hydronic Heat
· 15 min read
Whole House Fan Size and the Attic Vent Area It Needs
· 13 min read
Calculators for this topic
Boiler Size Calculator
The Net AHRI rating, Heating Capacity window and input for a hot water boiler from the heat loss, or a check of a boiler against the load.
Furnace Size Calculator
Whole-house heating load from a ZIP code and a short description of the house, with the furnace input bin.
BTU per Square Foot Calculator
Cooling and heating BTU/h per square foot by climate zone, from the whole-house load engine.
When a Permit Needs a Stamped Manual J
Where the line falls between sales-phase sizing and permit-grade submittal.
Run your own numbers in the free Manual J load calculator.