Maintained by BuildSolver · Updated
Calculator · HVAC
Heat pump vs furnace cost calculator
Heat from gas, propane, oil and electricity is sold in different units, so compare them as dollars per million BTU of heat that reaches the house. A furnace delivers its AFUE share of the fuel, resistance heat delivers all of the electricity, and a heat pump delivers its COP times the electricity. With the example prices on this page, gas costs $15.79 per MMBtu, a heat pump at COP 2.5 costs $21.50, and the heat pump breaks even with gas at a COP of 3.40. The prices are examples, not a forecast, so type your own. This page is heating only; for cooling cost use the SEER2 energy cost calculator, and for the COP to enter, the SEER, EER and COP conversion calculator.
- Type the annual heat need in MMBtu, the electricity price per kWh, and the gas price per therm. Add propane and heating oil prices if you want them compared, and clear both fields of a fuel to leave it out.
- Give the AFUE of each furnace or boiler from its nameplate, and a winter-average COP for the heat pump. HSPF2 divided by 3.412 gives a seasonal COP.
- The result shows dollars per million BTU of delivered heat and dollars per year for each option, which is cheapest, and the COP at which the heat pump costs the same as each fuel.
Example result for the default inputs
60 MMBtu of heat a year, electricity $0.1834 per kWh, heat pump COP 2.50, gas $1.50 per therm at 95% AFUE.
Heat pump
$1,290 per year
Gas furnace
$947 per year
Heat pump against gas
$343 more per year
Break-even COP against gas
3.40 COP
| Natural gas furnace | $15.79 per MMBtu, $947 a year. $1.50 per therm x 10 therms per MMBtu / 95% AFUE |
|---|---|
| Propane furnace | $33.38 per MMBtu, $2,003 a year. $2.90 per gallon x 1,000,000 / 91,452 BTU / 95% AFUE |
| Heating oil furnace or boiler | $32.28 per MMBtu, $1,937 a year. $3.80 per gallon x 1,000,000 / 138,500 BTU / 85% AFUE |
| Electric resistance | $53.75 per MMBtu, $3,225 a year. $0.1834 per kWh x 1,000,000 / 3,412 BTU, efficiency 1 |
| Heat pump | $21.50 per MMBtu, $1,290 a year. $0.1834 per kWh x 1,000,000 / 3,412 BTU / COP 2.50 |
| Cheapest | Natural gas furnace is cheapest at $15.79 per MMBtu, $947 a year. Next is heat pump at $21.50, $343 a year more. |
| Break-even COP against gas | 3.40 = $53.75 per MMBtu of electricity / $15.79. Your COP of 2.50 is below it, so natural gas furnace is the cheaper of the two. |
| Break-even COP against propane | 1.61 = $53.75 per MMBtu of electricity / $33.38. Your COP of 2.50 is at or above it, so the heat pump is the cheaper of the two. |
| Break-even COP against heating oil | 1.67 = $53.75 per MMBtu of electricity / $32.28. Your COP of 2.50 is at or above it, so the heat pump is the cheaper of the two. |
| Heat contents used | EIA: 1 kWh = 3,412 BTU, 1 therm = 100,000 BTU, propane 91,452 BTU per gallon, heating oil 138,500 BTU per gallon. |
| What this leaves out | Heat pump COP falls on the coldest days, and the winter average is yours to enter. Service, equipment cost, fixed monthly charges, delivery fees and time-of-use or demand rates are not included. Prices change; these are the ones you entered. |
For estimation purposes only. Consult a licensed engineer for final designs.
Sign up with your email. Back on this page in the same browser, your inputs are filled in. No card.
Free without signup
How the cost of heat is worked out
Every fuel is priced the same way: what a million BTU of the fuel costs to buy, divided by how much of it ends up as heat in the house. A furnace or boiler delivers its AFUE share of the fuel. Electric resistance delivers all of it. A heat pump delivers its COP times the electricity it uses, because it moves heat as well as making it. The heat content of each fuel comes from the U.S. Energy Information Administration. The prices and efficiencies are yours.
- Electricity
$/MMBtu = price per kWh x 1,000,000 / 3,4121 kWh is 3,412 BTU (EIA), so a million BTU of electricity is 293.1 kWh. At $0.1834 per kWh that is $53.75 per MMBtu.- Natural gas
$/MMBtu = price per therm x 101 therm is 100,000 BTU (EIA), so a million BTU is 10 therms. $1.50 a therm is $15.00 per MMBtu before the furnace efficiency is applied.- Propane
$/MMBtu = price per gallon x 1,000,000 / 91,452EIA lists propane at 91,452 BTU per gallon. $2.90 a gallon is $31.71 per MMBtu, about twice the gas price per unit of heat at these examples.- Heating oil
$/MMBtu = price per gallon x 1,000,000 / 138,500EIA lists heating oil at 138,500 BTU per gallon, so a gallon carries about 1.5 times the heat of a gallon of propane.- Furnace or boiler
delivered $/MMBtu = fuel $/MMBtu / (AFUE / 100)AFUE is the share of the fuel's heat that becomes space heat. The example gas furnace at 95% AFUE turns $15.00 of fuel into $15.79 per MMBtu of delivered heat.- Electric resistance
delivered $/MMBtu = electricity $/MMBtuAll of the electricity becomes heat, an efficiency of 1, so the delivered cost is $53.75 per MMBtu at the example rate.- Heat pump
delivered $/MMBtu = electricity $/MMBtu / COPCOP is heat out over electricity in. At a COP of 2.5 the example is $53.75 / 2.5 = $21.50 per MMBtu, 117.2 kWh for each million BTU.- Cost a year
$/year = delivered $/MMBtu x MMBtu a yearAt 60 MMBtu of heat a year the example gas furnace costs $947, the heat pump $1,290 and resistance heat $3,225.- Break-even COP
COP = electricity $/MMBtu / fuel delivered $/MMBtuThe COP at which the heat pump costs the same as the fuel. Against the example gas furnace it is 3.40, and in this example a heat pump averaging below that costs more to run than gas.
Seven price and COP cases for the same house
Each row heats the same 60 MMBtu a year. Row one is the example this page opens on: gas $15.79 and a heat pump $21.50 per MMBtu. Each later row changes one thing at a time, the electricity price, the furnace AFUE, the heat pump COP or the gas price, so you can see which input moves the answer. Prices here are examples, not a forecast.
| Case | What changes | Gas, $/MMBtu | Heat pump, $/MMBtu | Gas, $/year | Heat pump, $/year | Break-even COP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Example prices | $0.1834/kWh, gas $1.50/therm, 95% AFUE, COP 2.5 | $15.79 | $21.50 | $947 | $1,290 | 3.40 |
| Cheap electricity | $0.10/kWh, the rest as above | $15.79 | $11.72 | $947 | $703 | 1.86 |
| Expensive electricity | $0.30/kWh, the rest as above | $15.79 | $35.17 | $947 | $2,110 | 5.57 |
| Older 80% furnace | 80% AFUE gas, the rest as the example | $18.75 | $21.50 | $1,125 | $1,290 | 2.87 |
| Mild climate, COP 3.5 | COP 3.5, the rest as the example | $15.79 | $15.36 | $947 | $921 | 3.40 |
| Cold winter, COP 1.8 | COP 1.8, the rest as the example | $15.79 | $29.86 | $947 | $1,792 | 3.40 |
| Gas at $2.20 a therm | gas $2.20/therm, the rest as the example | $23.16 | $21.50 | $1,389 | $1,290 | 2.32 |
Carry the break-even COP to a customer as the single number: if the heat pump's winter average is above it, the heat pump is cheaper to run on these prices, and if it is below, gas is. It moves with the electricity price and the gas price, and it is the reason a heat pump pays in one house and not in the next.
Standards and data sources
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, British thermal units (Btu), Sample Btu conversion factors - the heat contents behind every row: 1 kilowatthour = 3,412 Btu, 1 therm = 100,000 Btu, propane 1 gallon = 91,452 Btu and heating oil 1 gallon = 138,500 Btu. EIA calls them samples, and the delivered heat content varies by a few percent.
- ENERGY STAR, Furnaces, Key Product Criteria - the definition of AFUE as the percentage of the heat in the incoming fuel which is converted to space heat instead of being lost, the federal test method behind it (10 CFR Part 430, Appendix N to Subpart B), and the ENERGY STAR levels of 95 (South) and 97 (North) AFUE for gas furnaces and 87 AFUE for oil furnaces.
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, Electric Power Monthly, Table 5.6.A - the default electricity price, $0.1834 per kWh, the U.S. residential average for June 2026. Gas, propane and oil prices on this page are round examples, not EIA figures.
Limitations of this calculator
- Prices are the numbers you type. The defaults are examples to show the arithmetic, not a forecast and not a survey, and fuel and electricity prices change by the month and by the utility or supplier. Use the latest bill or delivery ticket.
- A heat pump's COP is not one number. It falls as the outdoor air gets colder, and below the balance point backup heat takes over at a COP of 1. Enter a winter-season average for your climate, and see the heat pump balance point calculator for how much of the load the compressor carries.
- The result is a cost of heat at the average COP and AFUE you give. It does not simulate hourly weather, defrost cycles, or a variable-speed unit's changing efficiency.
- Furnace blower electricity, ignition and pilot energy, and the standby use of a heat pump are left out. A gas furnace also uses some electricity, and AFUE does not count it, so a gas furnace's true cost is slightly higher than shown.
- Rates with tiers, time-of-use periods or demand charges are not modeled, and neither are fixed monthly charges and delivery fees. Use an all-in average $/kWh and $/therm, with the fixed charge taken out unless the choice would remove the meter.
- Equipment price, installation, service, maintenance, rebates, tax credits and the cost of leaving a fuel service are not included, so this is a running-cost comparison only, not a payback or a life-cycle cost.
- Heat contents are EIA sample values. Propane and heating oil as delivered vary by a few percent, and gas is billed by the therm only after the utility applies its own heating value to the volume measured.
- The annual heat need is an input. This page does not work out a heat loss. It is heat delivered to the rooms, so a bill in fuel units must be multiplied by the furnace's AFUE first.
- Heating only. Cooling cost is on the SEER2 energy cost calculator. Preliminary estimate for comparing fuels, not an energy audit.
Common mistakes when comparing heating costs
- Comparing the price per unit. A therm of gas at $1.50 and a gallon of propane at $2.90 look close. Per million BTU they are $15.00 and $31.71, more than twice apart, because a gallon of propane holds 91,452 BTU and a therm 100,000. Convert every fuel to dollars per MMBtu first.
- Leaving out the furnace efficiency. Gas at $1.50 a therm is $15.00 per MMBtu in the pipe. Through a 95% AFUE furnace it is $15.79 per MMBtu in the house, and through an 80% furnace $18.75. That is $178 a year at 60 MMBtu.
- Using the rated COP as the winter COP. Spec sheets quote COP at a mild point such as 47F. A COP of 3.5 gives $921 a year in the example, and 1.8, a cold winter average, gives $1,792. The gas furnace is $947 either way. Use a seasonal figure, HSPF2 / 3.412, or less.
- Entering the heat bought instead of the heat delivered. The heat need is what reaches the rooms. A house that needs 60 MMBtu burns 63.2 MMBtu of gas in a 95% furnace, 631.6 therms. Entering the 63.2 MMBtu of fuel as the heat need overstates every yearly cost by about 5 percent. Convert a fuel bill to heat with the AFUE.
- Using a cooling rating for heating. SEER2 and EER2 describe cooling. The heating side of a heat pump is rated in HSPF2 and COP. Entering a SEER2 as a COP makes the heat pump look far better than it is. Convert the heating rating instead.
- Using the headline rate and ignoring tiers and fixed charges. The electricity price is the lever. At $0.10 per kWh the heat pump is $11.72 per MMBtu, under the $15.79 for gas. At $0.30 it is $35.17. Use the average rate the customer pays for the extra winter kWh, not the lowest tier.
Common questions about heat pump and furnace running cost
How do you compare the cost of heat from different fuels?
Put every fuel on the same basis: dollars per million BTU of heat delivered to the house. That is the fuel price per unit, converted with its heat content, divided by the efficiency. In the example, gas is $15.79 per MMBtu, a heat pump at COP 2.5 is $21.50, heating oil is $32.28, propane is $33.38 and electric resistance is $53.75.
How many BTU are in a therm, a gallon of propane, a gallon of heating oil and a kWh?
The EIA gives 1 therm = 100,000 BTU, 1 gallon of propane = 91,452 BTU, 1 gallon of heating oil = 138,500 BTU and 1 kWh = 3,412 BTU. A cubic foot of natural gas is about 1,036 BTU. These are sample values, and a delivery can differ by a few percent.
What COP does a heat pump need to cost less than gas?
The break-even COP is the electricity price per MMBtu divided by the gas cost per delivered MMBtu. At $0.1834 per kWh and gas at $1.50 a therm through a 95% AFUE furnace it is 3.40. At $0.10 per kWh it falls to 1.86, and at $0.30 it rises to 5.57. A winter-average COP above the break-even means the heat pump is cheaper to run.
What is AFUE and how does it enter the cost?
AFUE is the percentage of the heat in the fuel that is converted to space heat instead of being lost, measured by the federal test method. The delivered cost is the fuel cost divided by the AFUE. Gas costs $15.79 per delivered MMBtu through a 95% AFUE furnace and $18.75 through an 80% one.
Is a heat pump always cheaper than electric resistance heat?
Yes, at any COP above 1, because it delivers more heat for the same electricity. At COP 2.5 the heat pump costs $21.50 per MMBtu against $53.75 for resistance heat, about 40 percent of the cost. Below the balance point, backup strips run at a COP of 1.
What COP should I enter for a heat pump?
A winter-season average, not the rating at 47F. HSPF2 divided by 3.412 turns the seasonal rating into a COP: an HSPF2 of 8.5 is 2.49. Colder climates average lower because the compressor works at lower outdoor temperatures and the backup heat runs. Use the SEER, EER and COP conversion calculator to do the conversion.
Where do the default prices come from?
Electricity is priced at $0.1834 per kWh, the EIA residential average for June 2026. Gas, propane and oil prices are round examples chosen to show the arithmetic. They are not a forecast or a survey of any region. Replace all of them with the customer's own bills.
Does this include the cost of buying and installing the equipment?
No. It compares running costs only. Equipment price, installation, rebates, maintenance and the cost of removing a fuel service are separate, and a payback needs them. Take the yearly difference from this page to that comparison.
Is this the same as the dual-fuel switchover temperature?
No. A dual-fuel switchover is the outdoor temperature below which a hybrid system turns off the heat pump and fires the furnace. It follows the same cost comparison with a COP that changes with temperature. This page uses one average COP. The balance point calculator covers where the heat pump stops keeping up.